Coordination of Civil and Military Forces in Natural Disasters: A Systematic Review

Document Type : Review

Authors

1 Department of Anesthesiology, School of Medicine, Baqiyatallah al-Azam Hospital, Baqiyatallah University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

2 Department of Health in Disasters and Emergencies, School of Management and Medical Informatics, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran

3 Department of Health in Disasters and Emergencies, School of Nursing, AJA University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Background and Aim: We are bearing witness to the daily occurrence of natural disasters in various parts of the world. Considering the extensive presence of military forces for assistance and establishment of security in disaster-stricken regions, the importance of coordination between civil and military forces becomes clearer. The present study used a systematic review method to extract the factors influencing the enhancement of the military-civil forces’ coordination in natural disasters in various countries around the globe.
Methods: A systematic search was made in PubMed, Cochran Library, Scopus, EMBASE, Web of Science, and ProQuest between January 1970 and December 31, 2020. Articles were selected by the authors based on the search keywords including the three dimensions of "coordination", "disasters" and "military-civilian". The articles were selected based on keywords by the author. In the end, the factors influencing coordination were selected from the articles.
Results: After studying the titles, abstracts, and texts of all articles, 15 of them were selected for final analysis. There were 2 qualitative articles, 3 quantitative articles, 1 lesson learned article, 5 mix-method studies and 4 review articles. The most frequent factors in terms of repetition were information management (sharing and newness), planning, unit commanding, instruction, and communication. Analyzing the articles, there were two main approaches to disaster management in the world, which include the parallel and sequential coordination approach.
Conclusion: The results obtained from this systematic review provided an overview of the factors influencing civil-military forces’ coordination during natural disasters. Each of the factors was envisioned as a chain loop that caused more coordination in responding to disasters. Overall, all organizations involved in disaster management should play a role in codification of crisis management policies of every country, so that the important aspects and issues can be taken into account.

Keywords

References

1. Hall RA, Cular A. Civil-military relations in disaster rescue and relief activities: Response to the mudslide in southern Leyte, Philippines. Scientia Militaria: South African Journal of Military Studies. 2010;38(2):62-88. 2. Rietjens SJH. Civil-military cooperation in response to a complex emergency: just another drill?: Brill Leiden; 2008. 3. Nugroho SP, Pandanwangi TS, Suprapto S. Civil-Military Cooperation in Disaster Management. Jurnal Pertahanan. 2016;2(2):129-44. 4. Metcalfe V, Haysom S, Gordon S. Trends and challenges in humanitarian civil-military coordination: A review of the literature. London: The Humanitarian Policy Group. 2012. 5. Egnell R. Civil–military coordination for operational effectiveness: Towards a measured approach. Small Wars & Insurgencies. 2013;24(2):237-56. 6. Tatham P. Improving the civil-military dimension of disaster related humanitarian logistics. Asia Pacific Civil Military Centre of Excellence, Working Paper. 2011;1(11). 7. Cordesman AH. The Iraq War: strategy, tactics, and military lessons: CSIS; 2003. 8. Vorraber W, Lichtenegger G, Brugger J, Gojmerac I, Egly M, Panzenböck K, et al. Designing Information Systems to Facilitate Civil-Military Cooperation in Disaster Management. International Journal of Distributed Systems and Technologies (IJDST). 2016;7(4):22-40. 9. Chaisorn P. Civil-Military Cooperation in Disaster Relief Operations: A Case Study of the 2004 Sumatra-Andaman Earthquake Disaster Relief Operation in Thailand. National Defence Studies Institute Journal. 2017;8(2):47-60. 10. Nugroho SP, Pandanwangi TS, Suprapto S. Civil-military cooperation in disaster management. Jurnal Pertahanan: Media Informasi ttg Kajian & Strategi Pertahanan yang Mengedepankan Identity, Nasionalism & Integrity. 2016;2(2):129-44. 11. Bollettino V. Civil-military engagement: an empirical account of humanitarian perceptions of civil-military coordination during the response to Typhoon Haiyan. Disaster Med Public Health Prep. 2016;10(1):7-10. 12. Burke R. Lessons from Katrina: commanding the military during disaster response-then and now. International Journal of Emergency Management. 2016;12(3):221-40. 13. Thompson WC. Success in Kashmir: a positive trend in civil–military integration during humanitarian assistance operations. Disasters. 2010;34(1):1-15. 14. Berggren P, Nählinder S, Svensson E. Characteristics of Command and Control in Response to Emergencies and Disasters. Assessing Command and Control Effectiveness: CRC Press; 2017. p. 107-26. 15. Rietjens SJ, Verlaan K, Zaalberg TWB, De Boer SJ. Inter‐organisational communication in civil–military cooperation during complex emergencies: a case study in Afghanistan 1. Disasters. 2009;33(3):412-35. 16. McMaster R, Baber C. Multi-agency operations: cooperation during flooding. Applied ergonomics. 2012;43(1):38-47. 17. Salmon P, Stanton N, Jenkins D, Walker G. Coordination during multi-agency emergency response: issues and solutions. Disaster Prevention and Management: An International Journal. 2011;20(2):140-58. 18. Pramanik R. Challenges in coordination: differences in perception of civil and military organizations by comparing international scientific literature and field experiences. Journal of risk research. 2015;18(7):989-1007. 19. Scotter JRV, Pawlowski SD, Cu TD. An examination of interdependencies among major barriers to coordination in disaster response. International Journal of Emergency Management. 2012;8(4):281-307. 20. Czerwinski SJ. Disaster recovery: Experiences from past disasters offer insights for effective collaboration after catastrophic events: DIANE Publishing; 2010. 21. Bollettino V. Civil-military engagement: an empirical account of humanitarian perceptions of civil-military coordination during the response to Typhoon Haiyan. Disaster medicine and public health preparedness. 2016;10(1):7-10. 22. Malešič M. The impact of military engagement in disaster management on civil–military relations. Current sociology. 2015;63(7):980-98. 23. Joyce N. Civilian-military coordination in the emergency response in Indonesia. Military medicine. 2006;171(suppl_1):66-70. 24. Morris JC, Morris ED, Jones DM. Reaching for the philosopher’s stone: Contingent coordination and the military’s response to Hurricane Katrina. Public Administration Review. 2007;67:94-106. 25. Nabi PG. Coordinating post-disaster humanitarian response: lessons from the 2005 Kashmir earthquake, India. Development in Practice. 2014;24(8):975-88. 26. Salmon P, Stanton N, Jenkins D, Walker G. Coordination during multi‐agency emergency response: issues and solutions. Disaster Prevention and Management: An International Journal. 2011. 27. Araghizadeh H, Peyravi M, Sharififar S, Ahmadi Marzaleh M. Civil-military coordination in natural disasters: a qualitative study. Iranian Red Crescent Medical Journal. 2020;22(1). 28. Araghizadeh H, Peyravi M, Sharififar S, Marzaleh MA. Civil-Military Coordination (CIMIC) Model in Natural Disasters in Iran. Bulletin of Emergency & Trauma. 2020;8(4):218.
Journal of Military Medicine
Volume 23, Issue 6 - Serial Number 103
September and October 2021
Pages 555-563

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics